Thursday, April 22, 2010

The Inland Revenue Board (IRB)

As for many of us, we have to know, or must know this board as this is the authority who is taking all our taxes. Prior to March 1996, this board is actually called Department of Inland Revenue Malaysia, under the scrutiny of Ministry of Finance. As upon 1st March 1996, they became a Statutory Board, so call independent board.

The reason for today's post is simple that is to know their function and why is it important to know, because if next time you are working, you get to know who and how your tax money are used. Main thing to concern for IRB is that, they are responsible for
  1. Formulation of new tax policies for both the private and public sectors
  2. tax collection and
  3. compliance enforcement.
These are probably adapted from the slides, but having to know this are essential and with my beefed up information in the later section.

Functions of IRB
  • Act as an agent of the Malaysian Government and to provide services in administering, accessing, collecting and enforcing payment of taxes under the IRB
  • Advice the Malaysian Government on matters relating to taxation and to liaise with the appropriate Ministries and statutory bodies on such matters
  • Participate in or outside Malaysia in respect of matters relating to taxation
  • Perform such other functions as conferred on the Board by any other written law
  • Act as a collection agent for and on behalf of any body for the recovery of loans due for repayment to that body under any written law
And taxes under IRB will include income tax, petroleum income tax, real property gains tax, estate duties and stamp duties. And with that, we have also Malaysian Tax Academy who are in charge of guiding the team of people (who come and bugged you every year in the month of April)

The objectives of Malaysian Tax Academy are :-

  1. To provide training for the officers and staff of Inland Revenue Board of Malaysia in taxation and management to enable them to carry out their duties in a professional manner;
  2. To reinforce the knowledge and expertise of the officers and staff of Inland Revenue Board of Malaysia to meet the demands of a dynamic tax system;

  3. To widen the perspective and knowledge of the officers and staff of Inland Revenue Board of Malaysia through joint training with individuals and organisations within and outside the country; and

  4. To provide tax education to the public in order to enhance their knowledge and awareness regarding taxation in this country.


Wednesday, April 21, 2010

Let's see what Insurance Law have to say!

Jailed for biting off ear of lover’s husband

A TECHNICIAN who bit off the ear of his lover’s husband was jailed seven years and given eight strokes of the rotan by a court in Singapore.

China Press reported that the 42-year-old technician, who is a bachelor, committed the offence on June 18 last year at a Housing Development Board flat.

The technician’s lover had brought him back to her flat without realising that her husband was home. There was an argument between the two men which led to a fight and the biting of the ear.

The technician was arrested the same day.


Let's have this situation to think that, let's say the husband did purchased a life insurance. And probably he didn't know that his ears is so fragile (just joking) and let's don put sueing as part of the deal yet, will the insurance company be paying for his hospitality and services/treatment for his ears?

If you purchase life insurance, I have to say sorry but he won't be able to claim that. As this is considered as Personal Accident, and it shall be in another package called General Insurance, or you have to attach this plan as a rider to Life Insurance. How complicated it is? But sadly, this is true because judging from other point of view, this is an accident and is not something that we expect all living humans will have in their entire life. Thus, be smart in picking your insurance package! hehe..

Income Tax Law

Yes, finally one of the hottest topic, not just in law, but in politics in everywhere around the world. From how you can see it in US, Thailand (recently) and Malaysia (everyday). Everyone who is working above RM 32000 per anum (if I'm not mistaken) have to paid this tax, namely Income Tax.

And in fact, during this post is the time when the peak of the Income Tax Authority is waiting for our personal assessment to be sent to them before the big tax is coming. With that, every single year, the time for accountants will be busy is this month, October and December. But having said that, let's pop some questions for you, is Income Tax important for you?WHY? This will be the main agenda of our topic today.

Before we go on further, let's have some understanding what exactly tax are. Tax is a sum of money paid by the citizens to the government on the income or value of good purchases of certain specific goods and services. For individuals, we have income tax that is based on the amount that we earn and we have to give this contribution to the government. And as the relationship is directly from us to the government, the taxes that we paid from our income is called DIRECT TAXES. As for indirect taxes, is whereby our money is paid to the products or services that is charged with tax, which later will be paid by another agent to the authority. As for example, we go and eat in McD, and we have to paid for Government Tax of 5% , and that is indirect taxes.

So imagine, how many things we are paying for taxes nowadays. Even some Mamak (food stalls) and Chinese Hawker stalls nowadays require us to pay tax. And with the plan of having GST (goods and service tax) on everything we buy soon, wow, where is the money for us to even buy toilet papers? Just joking, but yes, as a country become more developed and with technology growing exponentially, more expenditure is to made from the Government bodies. And with 60-70% of Malaysia's income comes from tax, our country is depending on us, the smart and hardworking brats to fund for the country. WAIT A MINUTE!

Does it mean that tax is the main contributor to the Federal Government? Answer is YES! From the latest 3 years record (2007-2009) that I got from Bernama (click on this hood), 70.6% of our Federal Government Revenue amounting to RM 124, 379 millions are from taxes, this is the budget for this year (2009) actually. Alright, the actual amount collected on 2007 and 2008 were RM 95,168 millions and RM 107,737 millions respectively. And this collected amount stands in 68% (2007) and 66.5% (2oo8) in our country.

With that amount approximate 44% to 47% are coming from the income taxes. Be amazed with the figures below (click to enlarge)





And with that money, we citizens enjoy the infrastructure and facilities and improvement especially in standard of living. And back to our topic today, is Income Tax important for you? Definitely yes because if you do not pay it or submit your assessment you will be summoned, a huge amount of money. But is that the main important things? Simply NO, because the money that is taxed, you will try to minimize it as you want to have more money for yourself.

With that idea of 'more money for yourself', brings in the hot topic for country with taxes. Each and every year, Politics will fight each other and with 70% of our income is by tax, TAX is the topic that is always discussed. Click this link to read the latest story in America that was shared to me by Priya, our friend. The debate goes on, because with that huge amount of money, development is usually lack been seen in our country. I'm not saying that there are no developments, but the debate is always regarding that where the money goes, as with the budget, is money wisely managed.

As always, money is a sensitive issue and money makes the whole world goes round, you can see this effect that citizens will want their contribution to tax wisely used. And with that, some try to evade taxes partly not because they can't pay, but they don't wish their money to be used inefficiently. And this is the reason why I said this topic is hot. Still in introductory actually! hehe.

Tuesday, April 20, 2010

Human Rights and Country Law







Although part of our laws that we learnt are mostly regarding Business Law. But life is never all about business right. This is the recent video clips that I viewed that creates curiosity and questions regarding the law of justice in Malaysia.

I hope you guys can view it and tell me your opinion in terms of Law in Malaysia for this scenario while I hunt for more information regarding this issue. Kindly comment as doing a part for me to speculate. Thank you!

Doctrine of Utmost Good Faith

With lots of doctrine that our fellow lawyers have to know, and remember, we as the Business Law student should know it as well. In fact, the whole nation should be aware of this as this Doctrines are the one that is guiding us and helping us especially for human rights.

In insurance law, from the previous post, Doctrine of Utmost Good Faith is one of the most important element, not in other contracts, but solely on Insurance Contract. With the definition that, each party to a proposed contract is under a duty to disclose to the other all information which would influence his decision to enter into the contract, whether such information is requested or not.

AS simple as it is defines, it means a lot to make sure each and every word counts. In fact, good faith can be termed as genuine faith, and things that is genuine that is informed is to ensure trust from both parties. This is very important as the failure to fulfil or giving material information, will subject the other party to avoid the contract. As insurance contract are based on mutual trust, and with information definitely more well understood by each party, it is their job and responsibility to enlighten each other regarding it. The mutual trust and confidence bonding between the insured and the insurer can be termed as uberrimae fidei, the same meaning as utmost good faith.

A very important case of this can be adapted from the example of someone who had heart and lungs problem. However, though not disclosed in his life insurance, nothing happened until SARS strike through one day. The impact was heavy (as it is an acute pneumonia) causes the guy passed away due to it. And from the thorough inspection from the doctor with the report being given to the company, the company chose not to pay or compensate to the family because it is stated that the deceased did not notify that.

Thus, in this Doctrine, telling the right and actual information is very important. It is not like life that sometimes we can make assumptions, no, not a chance. And with that, do beware and keep your insurance agent knows everything bout you well.

Understanding Insurance Law

One of the key thing to understand insurance law as to compare with other laws will be what is the difference between INSURANCE and ORDINARY contract. This will sets a distinct understanding and for us to know better the content of what insurance law is all about.

In ordinary contract, the doctrine of utmost good faith (which we will have discussion on it later) is not applicable simply because other doctrine as mentioned earlier, remains dominance in the meaning. But in insurance law, the main key elements of it is DOCTRINE OF UTMOST GOOD FAITH. On the other hand, in ordinary contract, the INSURABLE INTEREST is not needed, while insurance contract, the insured must have insurable interest in the subject matter.

At some points, too many jargons are put on hold and you might not know what is it all about, like utmost good faith, insurable interest and etc. Here will be clarification part.

I will start with Insurable Interest! It is common that in everything we do, we could not get 100% guarantee or even warranty of everything. It is the same as risk, that not all of them can be insured by the insurance company but only the risks of an insurable interest. With that, the insurable interest stands in the meaning of interest (as with the things to be covered or wish to be taken care of, such as financially, the family n etc.) in the subject matter of a contract of insurance, and this gives the right to the insured to enforce the contract when things, unduly happened.

And let's put an example that S bought a life insurance from Company G. Apparently, one day, her house caught on fire due to someone accidentally flanked a cigarettes butt on her house garden. The whole house was destroyed nearly 50% of it, but S survived with minor injuries.
Let us speculate this situation that what is the insurable interest, with what can be and to be insured!
Answer: Insurable interest again, means the insurance are covering based on your interest of what to be cover. In this sense, as S bought only life insurance (which is her interest), she will be compensated based on things that incur to her life or health. But what about the destroyed house? Sorry to say is that, the house will no be insured, as that is not within her insurable interest. The minor injuries that she got will be insured but simply not the house, as she did not purchase the FireInsurance or etc.

But do not worry, as complicated as it sounds, Insurance Companies nowadays are thinking way ahead of us, not that they know that we will have those dangers, but their words are sweet to say 'it is a precautionary measure', or more proverb-ly sound, 'prevention is better than cure'. Companies nowadays, as mentioned in the previous post had many packages, which this will includes life, fire and some other elements, with our choice. For better or worse, we are more coward as compare to last time, we will buy the one with the highest probabilities.

Back to the topic is that, the amount of insurable interest is based on the pecuniary loss that was incurred. However, let's say you pay your car insurance yearly, and in the same year, you sold off your car, that transfer of ownership will mean that the insurable interest will no longer be valid. Let's speculate another scenario? As we know that Cyberjaya is popular with accidents, and second with renting cars. And let's say Abduh is a owner of many cars that he rents, and upon renting one of the car one day, someone who is racing and drifted his car into a ridge. The question is, will he be gaining his insurable interest?
Let's put some deeper thoughts on your mind, that Insurance Companies are not that stupid, as they will investigate the case that happen before releasing their payment to you, so how is it going to be?

Actually in this case, based on the Vehicle Insurance that Abduh possesed, with no transfer of ownership but just the matter of transfer of tenancy to the driver, he is entitled for the insurable interest. As according to Nanyang Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Salbiah, as long the ownership has not been transferred, Abduh still content for the insurable interest.
But it may be argued again that, that is Business or insurance for your business and it may not fit the category, and even worse, the business is not legal. Will he be insured?
At some point, based on Nanyang case, in fact, it is a different matter simply because this is for rental, and as far as business is concerned, without the legal rights, the insurer company can choose not to pay it. As again, speculate this issue!

Monday, April 19, 2010

Caveat Emptor: Sales of Goods Law

Before continuing on the long Insurance Act case, let's bring back to one of the most important element in the chapter of Sales of Goods. As we can realise that each and every lessons that is learnt throughout the course, have something to be remembered.

As thus far, from
Contract Law, we have Doctrine of Stare Decisis,
Company Law, we have Doctrine of Separate Legal Entitiy
Insurance Law, we have Doctrine of Utmost Good Faith, and
in this context we have Doctrine of Caveat Emptor.

Taken from the Latin language, Caveat Emptor simply means ' Let the buyer Beware '.

How cool was that? But sound rather vague..but let me clarify some stuffs regarding it.

From Wikipedia explanation it goes like this,

"Under the doctrine of caveat emptor, the buyer could not recover from the seller for defects on the property that rendered the property unfit for ordinary purposes. The only exception was if the seller actively concealed latent defects or otherwise made material misrepresentations amounting to fraud. Before statutory law, the buyer had no warranty of the quality of goods. In many jurisdictions now, the law requires that goods must be of "merchantable quality". However, this implied warranty can be difficult to enforce and may not apply to all products. Hence, buyers are still advised to be cautious"

What does it mean is simply that, sellers should bear in mind the important elements of telling the truth. Of course, you and I know that in the real world, people will say that you won't earn money if you are telling the truth. But what let the buyer beware tells is that, the buyer should know the products and at some point, it is the seller's responsibility to ensure that the product is merchantable, or sell-able. This is essentially important, as many of us, can fall into a trap that this cases is actually a fraud or misrepresentation case. And as so many bad cases around the world, the only best method to counter this, is that, the buyer although guarded by this doctrine, should be smart and wise to choose and pick the right things, and know the right stuff.

And speculating on a small issue, let's put my name in this scenario, fictional but can happen.

Eric is eating in a Mamak Stall, and is having his sumptuous Nasi Kandar (wuallaa!). Having to savor his meal halfway, the waiter who served him earlier, walked to his side and wrote on the bill and placed it below the cup of his drink. Enjoying his food to the optimum, Eric did not flip the paper or bothered on the price? He is just too into the food. Great!!! And later after maximizing his marginal utility, he went to the counter wanting to pay before realising that the bill noted RM 15 ++.

Oh he goes, 'WOW, watha" and recalled what he just ate.
A plate of rice, with muttons and carry on top. No vege, no papadum, nothing extra. Just rice and mutton and curies. And what did he drink: Ice Tea.

In this situation, some people will just go, "S**t,we got cheated and this is very expensive, but never bother asking". And this is why a lot of stalls are taking advantage. But having listen to a talk by Prof. Dr. Ishak, from Sime Darby Corporate Culture Team, he shared that, this is all within our will to, simply, ASK. He said, "I know you guys ate the food, and the guy might be complaining that you taken a lot of mutton (which apparently is always taken by them), and all sort of reason. But the courtesy is still to ASK, to KNOW and to caution our RIGHTS".

Thus, in this scenario, don't be afraid to stand up, we are not picking up a fight, but just to ask and know, and if they usually charges that way, simply don't go and eat there anymore. But if not, you may stand in the chance of not paying that much.

FYI: Caveat venditor is Latin for "let the seller beware". It is a counter to caveat emptor and suggests that sellers can also be deceived in a market transaction. This forces the seller to take responsibility for the product and discourages sellers from selling products of unreasonable quality. In the landmark case of MacPherson v. Buick Motor Co. (1916), New York Court Appeals Judge Benjamin N. Cardozo established that privity of duty is no longer required in regard to a lawsuit for product liability against the seller. This case is widely regarded as the origin of caveat venditor as it pertains to modern tort law in US.